Following the lead of the 11 metro areas, the 10-City Composite matched last month’s record decline of 19.1% and the 20-City Composites set a new record, down 18,2%.
“The freefall in residential real estate continued through November 2008,” says David M. Blitzer, Chairman of the Index Committee at Standard & Poor’s. “Since August 2006, the 10-City and 20-City Composites have declined every month – a total of 28 consecutive months. Every region was down in excess of 1% for the November/October period, with eight of the regions recording record monthly declines. Phoenix and Las Vegas were the worst performers for the month at -3.4% and -3.3%, respectively, and also have the lowest returns over the one-year period, returning -32.9% and -31.6% respectively. Overall, more than half of the metro areas had record annual declines.
As of November 2008, average home prices are at similar levels to what they were in the first quarter of 2004. From their peak in mid-2006, the 10-City Composite is down 26.6% and the 20-City Composite is down 25.1%.
Monthly data also continues to show a housing market in decline. All 20 metro areas, and the two composites, posted their third consecutive monthly decline. In addition, eight of the MSAs posted their largest monthly decline on record – Atlanta, Boston, Charlotte, Chicago, Dallas, New York, Portland and Seattle. Although in decline over the past few years, some these regions have out-performed on a relative basis, when compared to the national average. It is clear, however, that the declines in home prices is affecting all regions regardless of geography or employment opportunities.
Dallas and Denver faired the best in November, in terms of relative year-over-year returns. While in negative territory, their declines remained in low single digits of -3.3% and -4.3%, respectively. It should be noted, Charlotte reported its third consecutive largest monthly decline on record, down -1.9%. Denver and Cleveland were the best reporting markets for the month returning -1.1% and -1.2%, respectively. On a relatively positive note, eight of the 20 metro areas recorded better annual returns compared to last month.
LOCALLY
The Standard & Poors/Case-Shiller Home Prices Indices 10 City Composite and 20 City Composite privides us with a national perspective. For the South Coast County of Santa Barbara (Carpinteria thru Goleta) the trend is the same but the numbers are different.
If we compare the local median sales prices for the years of: 2005 of $1,250,000; 2006 $1,190,000; 2007 of $1,231,750 and then take an average of those three years it is $1,223,917. Comparing this figure with the year ending median sales price for 2008 of $1,035,000 we note a drop of -15% in median sales price
This is approximately within 1% of the local median sales price for the year 2004 of $1,005,000. This same year was also interestingly mentioned by Case-Shiller in their national comparison for current levels in median sales price.
When the final numbers trickle in we may see the year 2004 used as a comparative benchmark for the median sales price in 2008, perhaps nationally and locally.
